Increasing Workers Compensation Medical Costs are Major Concern to P/C Insurers
Washington, D.C. – Workers compensation medical expense costs are growing at a rate far exceeding the increases in group health costs, and this will be a critical issue for property/casualty insurers and actuaries, attendees at the Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar were told.
Peter Rauner, FCAS and President, RMS Solutions, Inc. gave an overview of the significance of the workers compensation insurance market, explaining that workers compensation is the largest commercial line and the largest source of industry loss reserves among property/casualty insurers. He framed the issue by describing how medical expenses are a large and growing portion of workers compensation benefits. According to NCCI data, in 1986, medical expenses accounted for 45% of the total claim costs, with indemnity accounting for 55%. In 2006, medical expenses had grown to 59% of the total workers compensation claim costs. In addition, workers compensation medical severities are growing at a rate well above the medical CPI growth rate.
“Over the last eight years, workers compensation medical costs have nearly doubled, from about $13.5 billion in 1999 to over $25 billion in 2007 -- that’s staggering,” Rauner declared.
Rauner outlined some of the factors driving medical costs on a macro level, such as inflation, economic growth, provider consolidation, and lifestyle factors like increasing obesity and diabetes.
“The increasing medical costs trends are a very real concern to the property/casualty industry,” he stated. “The spiraling costs will not only impact workers compensation insurance, but also the industry as a whole.”
William Miller, FCAS, Senior Vice President and Actuary, ACE USA explained how workers compensation medical costs compared to group health costs. While they utilize essentially the same resources, there are major differences, which are driven by coverages and policy terms, political and regulatory pressures, and the duration of medical payout.
“While group health includes disincentives for overutilization, workers compensation has no coinsurance payment by the injured worker,” explained Miller. “Utilization is one of the primary reasons that workers compensation costs are rising so dramatically.”
Miller used an NCCI study to drive home his point. The study looked directly at utilization for 12 injuries and compared services provided within three months of injury. It was found that workers compensation costs were 71% more than group health costs across the 12 injuries, driven primarily by increased office visits and physical therapy.
“Workers compensation injuries result in more intense and costly treatments earlier on than under group health,” said Miller.
Miller encouraged the actuaries in attendance to use their analytical skills to help design efficient workers compensation medical coverages.
“Use predictive modeling to find which doctors are providing the best outcomes for getting workers back to work and staying at work,” urged Miller, as he outlined the keys to containing utilization. He also cited medical fee schedules, utilization reviews, managed provider networks, and pharmacy benefit management programs as keys to an ideal workers compensation medical system.
Erik Johnson, FCAS, Consultant and Actuary, Aon Global Risk Consulting, moderated the session, which was organized by the CAS Committee on Health Care Issues. The Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar was held September 18-19, 2008. The Seminar is jointly sponsored by the Casualty Actuarial Society and American Academy of Actuaries.
The Casualty Actuarial Society fulfills its mission to advance actuarial science through a focus on research and education. Among its 4,900 members are experts in property-casualty insurance, reinsurance, finance, risk management, and enterprise risk management. The American Academy of Actuaries’ mission is to serve the public on behalf of the U.S. actuarial profession. The Academy assists public policymakers on all levels by providing leadership, objective expertise, and actuarial advice on risk and financial security issues. The Academy also sets qualification, practice, and professionalism standards for actuaries in the United States.
Mike Boa, Director of Marketing and Communications